| 1 | Tue 8 Aug 2023 | 63-0 v Birtley TownPontefract Collieries 3-0 Birtley Town | Emirates FA Cup Extra Preliminary Round |
| 2 | Sat 12 Aug 2023 | 61-2 v Carlton TownPontefract Collieries 1-2 Carlton Town | Northern Premier League - East Division |
| 3 | Tue 22 Aug 2023 | 42-3 v Hebburn TownPontefract Collieries 2-3 Hebburn Town | Northern Premier League - East Division |
| 4 | Sat 26 Aug 2023 | 21-0 v Cleethorpes TownCleethorpes Town 0-1 Pontefract Collieries | Northern Premier League - East Division |
| 5 | Mon 28 Aug 2023 | 24-0 v Ossett UnitedPontefract Collieries 4-0 Ossett United | Northern Premier League - East Division |
| 6 | Sat 2 Sep 2023 | 63-1 v Belper TownBelper Town 1-3 Pontefract Collieries | Northern Premier League - East Division |
| 7 | Sat 9 Sep 2023 | 21-3 v Stockton TownStockton Town 3-1 Pontefract Collieries | Isuzu FA Trophy First Qualifying Round |
| 8 | Sat 16 Sep 2023 | 2 2-0 v Stockton TownPontefract Collieries 2-0 Stockton Town | Northern Premier League - East Division |
| 9 | Sat 23 Sep 2023 | 2 2-0 v Consett AFCConsett AFC 0-2 Pontefract Collieries | Northern Premier League - East Division |
| 10 | Sat 30 Sep 2023 | 22-2 v Grantham TownGrantham Town 2-2 Pontefract Collieries | Northern Premier League - East Division |
| 11 | Tue 3 Oct 2023 | 26-2 v SteetonSteeton 2-6 Pontefract Collieries | The West Riding County Cup |
| 12 | Sat 7 Oct 2023 | 21-1 v DunstonPontefract Collieries 1-1 Dunston | Northern Premier League - East Division |
| 13 | Sat 14 Oct 2023 | 22-1 v SheffieldSheffield 1-2 Pontefract Collieries | Northern Premier League - East Division |
| 14 | Sat 28 Oct 2023 | 2 1-2 v Ashington AFCAshington AFC 2-1 Pontefract Collieries | Northern Premier League - East Division |
| 15 | Sat 4 Nov 2023 | 52-2 v Brighouse TownPontefract Collieries 2-2 Brighouse Town | Northern Premier League - East Division |
| 16 | Sat 11 Nov 2023 | 64-1 v Winterton RangersWinterton Rangers 1-4 Pontefract Collieries | Northern Premier League - East Division |
| 17 | Tue 21 Nov 2023 | 51-0 v LiversedgeLiversedge 0-1 Pontefract Collieries | The West Riding County Cup Second Round |
| 18 | Sat 25 Nov 2023 | 52-1 v Grimsby BoroughGrimsby Borough 1-2 Pontefract Collieries | Northern Premier League - East Division |
| 19 | Tue 28 Nov 2023 | 2 2-1 v LiversedgePontefract Collieries 2-1 Liversedge | Northern Premier League - East Division |
| 20 | Fri 15 Dec 2023 | 50-2 v Consett AFCPontefract Collieries 0-2 Consett AFC | Northern Premier League - East Division |
| 21 | Tue 19 Dec 2023 | 22-1 v Rossington MainRossington Main 1-2 Pontefract Collieries | Friendly |
| 22 | Tue 26 Dec 2023 | 22-1 v Stocksbridge Park SteelsPontefract Collieries 2-1 Stocksbridge Park Steels | Northern Premier League - East Division |
| 23 | Sat 30 Dec 2023 | 24-0 v Ossett UnitedOssett United 0-4 Pontefract Collieries | Northern Premier League - East Division |
| 24 | Sat 6 Jan 2024 | 22-2 v Cleethorpes TownPontefract Collieries 2-2 Cleethorpes Town | Northern Premier League - East Division |
| 25 | Sat 13 Jan 2024 | 2 3-3 v Hebburn TownHebburn Town 3-3 Pontefract Collieries | Northern Premier League - East Division |
| 26 | Sat 3 Feb 2024 | 20-0 v Stockton TownStockton Town 0-0 Pontefract Collieries | Northern Premier League - East Division |
| 27 | Sat 17 Feb 2024 | 21-0 v Grantham TownPontefract Collieries 1-0 Grantham Town | Northern Premier League - East Division |
| 28 | Tue 20 Feb 2024 | 20-1 v North FerribyNorth Ferriby 1-0 Pontefract Collieries | Northern Premier League - East Division |
| 29 | Tue 27 Feb 2024 | 63-2 v Campion AFCPontefract Collieries 3-2 Campion AFC | The West Riding County Cup Quarter Final |
| 30 | Tue 23 Apr 2024 | 153-0 v Belper TownPontefract Collieries 3-0 Belper Town | Northern Premier League - East Division |
| 31 | Sat 27 Apr 2024 | 162-2 v Newton AycliffeNewton Aycliffe 2-2 Pontefract Collieries | Northern Premier League - East Division |
Football Web Pages